garota: Interview with ABC Radio

random musings of a disparate nomad

Wednesday, June 22, 2005

Interview with ABC Radio

Thanks for all the emails and SMSes re the interview. It’s been cropped a fair bit for the program, but here, as requested – the transcript. I’ve left out the bits by Jimmy Koh, Daryl Fong and others. Nah.

***
Richard Aedy: Back in Australia, among today’s international students, it seems there are growing grievances about the quality of the education that they’re getting for the tens of thousands that they pay. And in some states, that’s compounded by other issues – like a refusal to give international students concessions for public transport.

Me: The bureaucrats assume that international students are these rich punks who can afford the ridiculous fees that they put on us, and so therefore we must be able to afford that little bit more for transport. And that’s actually a really inaccurate assumption. There are many, many international students whose families are from a poor background. So they’ve invested a lot, basically, in sending their children here.

The irony is how much they go on about internationalising education more, attracting more international students, having a more diverse community. But when you put that against a simple thing like transport concessions, it doesn’t have to take that much away from the $5.9 billion that international students contribute to the Australian economy. And yet, [this] – it’s something that’s pissing international students off, honestly.

Fees is probably the largest consideration for most international students. The thing is, we have an ESOS Act (which stands for Education Services for Overseas Students), and that is supposed to protect us from increasing fees midway through our programs. Now, a couple of universities (at least) have tried to circumvent that by including this disclaimer, that fees are subject to changes, in the Certificate Of Enrolment.

Jonathan Gadir: So basically what we’re talking about is, in the middle of a course, suddenly the university says to you, oh sorry, the price [has] gone up.

Me: Yes. A lot of international students, and their families, save up an entire lifetime of savings in order to send their kid here. And [Australia’s] not a cheap place to live in. The cost of living is high. The bulk of international students come from China, India and South East Asia, where the currency exchange is not favourable, and the cost of living is a lot lower. So to come from that context to [Australia] is a big leap and it’s a very big financial strain on a lot of them.

JG: Is Australia becoming a second-best option, given these things?

Me: Yes, increasingly so. In the past, Australia used to be a good combination of low cost and fairly prestigious degree. But now with the increasing costs, they’re becoming on par if not more [in costs] than some UK and US universities – that’s the perception among many Asian countries, in light of the increasing fees – that they can get a comparable, if not higher quality education, elsewhere.


Technorati: , ,

6 Comments:

Blogger rench00 said...

i'd say leave it to market forces. if the prices are too high, then foreign students who can't afford don't go to australia. the australian government does not owe international students an education. the government's first and foremost duty is to run the country, not be a charity that provides cheap university education for students who are not their citizens.

but i do agree that it's a pain in the ass if they decide to raise the fees mid-course. that's just cheating.

22/6/05 12:07

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Education is expensive but its cheaper compared to the price of say..Ignorance? Im also a firm believer in charging the price which the commodity's value is supposed to be. If you halve the price of University Tuition fees...im quite sure no one would really care whether they did well in Uni or not because they'd sit for it again since its so cheap. How valuable something is to someone, is influenced (to a certain extent) by the price they pay for it too!

Providing affordable education to your country's citizen's is a first priority, thats true. Prices should be lower for local students as being a citizen of Australia should afford you that much at least. That doesnt mean that education for international students should be exorbitant to compensate. I think that is the point Garota is trying to make and in no way suggesting that UNSW, RMIT or any other Australian University become a Charity and start lowering university fees.

-JW

22/6/05 14:21

 
Blogger garota said...

rench: i will believe in market forces the day i see the 'trickle-down effect'. also, i see the enjoyment of economic (and other) development as a privilege that is not unaccompanied by some form of ethical responsibility. only imho, of course.

JW: ah yes, the emergence of homo economicus. it would interest me to see the development of your interpretation of this over the next 4 years. :) also, i do lament the dramatic fee surge at universities, although i must also qualify that it is the federal shirking of public responsibility in the education sector that i have deeper issues with.

23/6/05 06:09

 
Blogger garota said...

juzhen: lol. the operative, i agree. same for the visual dysfunction. and yay for +ve media!

25/6/05 07:08

 
Blogger garota said...

one thing though. i can't deny my disappointment that my comments about equity (re travel concessions) and silencing dissent (re VSU) got snipped off. those were actually 2 of my more important points.

25/6/05 23:05

 
Blogger Lemming said...

[claps hands]
Yay garota!

25/6/05 23:56

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

 

garota productions 2005